Kingdom of Sleep by E K Johnston

33310537

After really loving E K Johnston’s A Thousand Nights I shouldn’t be surprised that I was a little bit disappointed with her next offering. To be fair though, that’s on me more than on Johnston – I was never going to love a retelling of Sleeping Beauty (the title character does nothing/ heroic prince and damsel-in-distress princess/ true love’s kiss – bleurgh!) anywhere near as much as a retelling of Scheherazade’s story. And while Kingdom of Sleep lacks some of the cleverness and sheer beauty of A Thousand Nights, frankly, if all YA fiction was to this standard it would still be a vast improvement. One of my small gripes with this companion novel is that it reads YA in a way that the first book definitely did not. And the romance is both predictable, unavoidable (considering the source material) and … sorry … too squishy for me.

That said, I loved the way Johnston went about the romance. Yes, I could see it coming a mile away, but I liked the gentle humour involved (particularly Yashaa’s unbelievable ignorance of certain biological matters, which meant there was no … ahem … petty fingers, or worse), the rather tender way in which it unfolded, and the ending. I can’t say anything about that without utterly spoiling the book, but I’d recommend it because of the conclusion alone. I imagine poor young teen readers will find it heart-breaking *evil chuckle*, but I thought it was a pretty fresh approach to a story ending that’s been done to death. (And I might have felt just a little sympathy for Yashaa and Zahrah … maybe … but don’t tell anyone).

I liked, too, that this was a story with friendship at its heart. Yashaa, Saoud, Tariq and Arwa are friends who love and respect one another throughout the story. They have become family to one another through loss and necessity. There’s no rivalry, no love triangles, no ridiculous fallings-out to further the plot or to create tension. The silliest thing is Yashaa’s hatred for the Little Rose at the beginning of the book, and thankfully that didn’t last long enough for me to get cross with him.

On the flip side, I found that some things didn’t quite sit right with me. The curse, for example, is the work of a demon here, a part of its long game of manipulation and power-gathering, but in this context it didn’t ever quite make narrative sense. From the moment you know the curse’s full intent you know how it can be shut down, which means the reader can see the ending coming (not the absolute ending, just the ending for the demon), and that meant that I could never quite be as afraid of the demon’s threats as I might have been. Also, while I really loved the piskys and the gnomes, they felt a bit out of place in this mostly desert-fringe setting. A forensic archaeologist IRL who has worked in the Middle East, Johnston’s world feels authentic most of the time (one of the things I really enjoyed about A Thousand Nights) and I loved that she decided to keep writing within that setting, but the piskys and gnomes are, for me, so tied up with British mythology and therefore the British landscape, that I struggled to transpose them into her Eastern world. Again, that’s on me.

 

This may not make a whole lot of sense, but what really kept bothering me as I read this was the shape it was making in my mind. Once I’ve read a book it kind of solidifies into a particular shape, a set of images and colours, ideas and feelings that I then file away. So, A Thousand Nights is a perfect egg-shaped story, purple, orange and hot-pink, sprinkled all over with gold, that smells of incense and a cool building in summer. The images of an empty, rolling desert and a beautifully embroidered salwar kameez come to mind when I think of it, and I feel content and pleased. It is a ‘neat’ story, all ends tied off, plot well crafted and executed. (There’s so much more than this: a brown-gold horse, a bedside table, a garden, a plate of figs, the smells that go with these things …) Every book I read becomes a sensory package that’s difficult to unpack or explain, but all my favourites are shaped right. And sadly, while I enjoyed it and would still recommend it, Kingdom of Sleep isn’t quite the right shape. It’s like a piece of embroidery that’s untidy on the reverse.

Clearly I don’t know how to put this into words properly. As a matter of interest, please tell me how you think of books after you’ve read them? Do you categorise and file them in your mind? Do you come to a solid conclusion, or do you remain fluid in your thinking about a book? Are your other senses involved? Do you see images/snapshots when you think of a particular book? I’d love to know other people’s thoughts/feelings on this subject.

12 thoughts on “Kingdom of Sleep by E K Johnston

  1. I also like neat tidy stories, but I hadn’t really thought about the after image. That’s got me thinking I’ll have to get back to you on that one.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Interesting review! I don’t see read books as shapes, but I associate them with a particular feeling and certain sensory memories of the time I’ve been reading them – for each book it forms a unique experience 🙂 I usually form a pretty clear opinion of each book I read, and it rarely changes afterward – but it can take some time for me to form it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Cool! That sounds very much like what my husband Thumbs described to me when I asked him this question. I like the idea that going back to a book can take you back to your memories of when you first read it. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I like E.K. Johnston! It’s funny though, I only discovered her after she wrote a Star Wars book. I’d be interested in checking out her other YA work. Maybe I should check out A Thousand Nights, as it sounds like you had a better time with that one?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh wow, yes! A Thousand Nights is just a fab book – I heartily recommend it. This was good too, but I obviously read the best book first. 🙂
      I had no idea E K Johnston had written a Star Wars book! I hadn’t heard of her before I picked up A Thousand Nights.

      Like

      1. Up until something triggers a need for it and my mental filing system goes into action. But it is one of the reasons I do such spoilery reviews. I’m simply not going to remember that stuff in 10 years (most likely) so I better write it down now 🙂

        But in general, I can wax pretty loquacious about a book if you hit the right triggers. I just never know what those trigger points will be :-/

        Liked by 1 person

  4. That’s really cool how you describe the “shape” of a book after you read it! I can’t say my impressions of a book are so sensory or vivid, but it definitely does solidify into something round-ish in my mind. Of course, that’s only if the book was actually any good; the bad ones just form spikes and zig-zags in my head. 😂

    Terrific review btw! I’m curious to read A Thousand Nights as I’ve always been fascinated by Scheherazade, so I’ll be sure to put it on my TBR. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s